Delve into the complex legacy of Jean-Marie Le Pen, the notorious founder of the French far-right, whose rhetoric shaped and polarised political discourse in France. Discover his controversial history and enduring influence.
This article is also published in Bill Dowell’s personal Substack column: A Different Place.
Before Donald Trump’s politically driven hate campaign against undocumented immigrants, France was forced to deal with its own right-wing populist firebrand, Jean-Marie Le Pen.
Le Pen, who died earlier this month at the age of 96, began his political career when he was elected in 1956 as one of the youngest deputies in history to France’s National Assembly. At the time, Le Pen, who was only 27, had allied himself with Pierre Poujade, a bookstore owner who organized a grassroots, protest campaign to convince small shop owners to refuse to pay French taxes. Poujade had started life as an ordinary laborer and had initially sympathized with Philippe Pétain, who collaborated with Hitler in agreeing to the establishment of Vichy France. With only a limited education, he adopted a number of conspiracy theories, including the conviction that the National Assembly was infested with corrupt profiteers, that France’s Grandes Ecoles were working against French interests, and that many of France’s political problems were caused by meddling from the American CIA. Both Poujade and Le Pen shared a natural sympathy with many of the rightwing populist ideas that had circulated widely in Europe in the lead-up to World War II, and that finally morphed into German and Italian Fascism. .
Throughout his career, Le Pen attributed his popularity to a simple formula. “I say out loud,” he said frankly, “what you feel in your gut.” The message had its appeal, particularly in a time of turmoil. Civilization requires repressing bestial instincts and that takes energy. Le Pen’s argument was to relax and et it all hang out. What he was really expressing, however, also had a lot to do with France’s traumatic experiences during the Algerian War and the dismantling of France’s colonial empire that came soon after.
The Algerian War, which signaled the ultimate end to French colonialism, deeply divided French society and ultimately led to a coup attempt on May 13, 1958, in which several French generals, including Raoul Salan, and Admiral Philippe Aboyneau, commanding France’s Mediterranean fleet, along with France’s former governor in Algeria, Jacques Soustelle, tried to launch a putsch in an attempt to overthrow the government in Paris. The coup eventually failed but in the process, it triggered the collapse of France’s Fourth Republic and the return of Charles de Gaulle as president of France’s Fifth Republic. De Gaulle was welcomed largely due to the expectation that he would use the French Army to keep Algeria as part of France. Instead, de Gaulle decided to negotiate Algeria’s independence and an end to the war. Although it was the right thing to do, it led to decades of bitterness and anger dividing the French Right from the French Left.
Despite de Gaulle’s best efforts, France remained deeply conflicted concerning Algeria. Dissident officers in the French Army formed a rebellious terrorist group calling itself the OAS, the Organization of the Secret Army. The group repeatedly tried to assassinate DeGaulle including the incident that came to be known as the “Day of the Jackal.” De Gaulle responded to the OAS by forming a “parallel” police force, calling itself SAC, Service Action Civique. SAC gave the government the cover it needed to engage in assassinations against the OAS. It was eventually accused of also engaging in political fundraising and eventually in running various narcotics operations, including the French connection, smuggling heroin into New York.
In the chaotic environment produced by the fight over Algeria, Le Pen took a leave of absence from the National Assembly and volunteered to join French paratroopers who had been thrown into a brutal campaign to stamp out Algeria’s FLN, the National Liberation Front, which was leading Algeria’s native resistance.
Le Pen’s role as a volunteer paratrooper led to his being later referred to as having engaged in torture by several French newspapers including the political newspaper Le Canard Enchainé. Le Pen sued the Canard for libel. Instead of yielding to the suit, The Canard Enchainé dispatched a team of reporters to Algeria to find the people whom Le Pen had personally tortured. One of the witnesses said that torture from the French paratroopers had been so vicious that he had tried to commit suicide by trying to cut his jugular vein with a shard of glass from a shattered milk bottle. Lieutenant Le Pen, he said, had then allegedly returned to the hospital with some soldiers and demanded that the Algerian be released so that the torture could continue. A French Army captain, who was the doctor in charge, had interceded and told Le Pen that the French Army was in command and that Le Pen should leave. The witness’s testimony was bolstered by the fact that after returning from Algeria, Le Pen had given a speech to the National Assembly arguing that torture had worked in Algeria and might work very well in France’s domestic judicial system.
The judge in the libel trial eventually ruled that the witnesses’ testimony should be excluded since the French government had amnestied all war crimes in Algeria in1968.
But, the judge added, Le Pen had made it clear in his various statements that he approved of torture, and therefore, he could not claim that he considered being labeled as a torturer to be libelous. The newspapers were in the clear.
In 1962, Le Pen lost his seat in the National Assembly and decided to go into private business. Joining in a partnership with Leon Gaultier, who had previously served with the Nazi Waffen SS, he launched a publishing company called SERP (Society for Study and Public Relations), which specialized in reprinting speeches by Adolph Hitler, Benito Mussolini, the Waffen SS, and various organs of the Nazi Third Reich. The company became a rallying point for Nazi sympathizers and extreme right reactionaries still smarting over the loss of Algeria. As Le Pen moved forward politically, most Parisians had forgotten about Le Pen’s involvement in SERP. A popular French TV interviewer, Michel Polac, questioned SERP’s activities on a leading TV interview show, Droite de Response—Right to Answer, and pointed out that the company was happily distributing Waffen SS marching songs. I went by the store on Paris’ Rue du Bac. The store manager said, “The business has no connection to Mr. Le Pen’s work in the National Front. This is his personal business.”
By 1972, Le Pen had gathered enough extreme-rightists to launch his own party, the Front National, which presented itself as leaning to the right in conservative French politics. The neo-Nazis were still there, but the party began reaching out and trying to incorporate those members of French society who had more centrist views. Le Pen was aided financially by Hubert Lambert, the troubled heir of a family that had made a fortune from the production of cement. Lambert, who was fascinated by Le Pen, left him a fortune when he died in 1976. Despite his attempts to compete in conventional French politics, Le Pen remained an admirer of Hitler’s Third Reich. At a press luncheon, I once asked him about his condemnation before a French court for having said that Hitler had been a democratically elected leader of Germany. “The French courts and I have a difference of opinion,” he replied.
As Le Pen aged, his daughter, Marine, became more active in the National Front. Unlike her father, she had learned to moderate what she was willing to say out loud. In 1990, Jean-Marie Le Pen casually remarked that the Holocaust and Hitler’s gas chambers had been a historical detail emerging from World War II. That was too much both for the French public and for Marine Le Pen. Jean-Marie was ejected from the Front National, and in 2018, Marine Le Pen changed the party’s name to “National Rally.” By then, she had reconciled, at least in her role as a daughter, with her father.
To his credit, Jean-Marie Le Pen remained honest about his political ideology until the bitter end. He was a Nazi to the end. Marine Le Pen, in softening the edges of her father’s thinking in order to make his ideas more politically acceptable to a much larger segment of French society, may be less forthright than her father, but she is potentially more dangerous. Her reshaped version of her father’s party risks enticing less extremist conservatives and middle-of-the-road French voters into a political organization whose ultimate goals remain far darker and more sinister than they appear to be on the surface.
German and Italian fascists began by announcing seemingly reasonable plans to improve society. Mainly, they claimed, they wanted to make the railroads run on time. They ended by promoting Nazi gas chambers and dragging the entire planet into a global war. Even when the devastation caused by World War II became obvious to everyone, Jean-Marie Le Pen insisted on continuing down the same failed path to disaster. Luckily, France chose to relegate him to the sidelines. Let’s hope that the future is smart enough to do the same.
Veteran foreign correspondent and author William Dowell is Global Insights Magazine’s America’s editor based in Philadelphia where he writes his regular Tom’s Paine column. He is also a contributing editor to Who,What,Why. Dowell has worked for ABC News and other news organizations, including TIME Magazine in Hong Kong, Cairo, and Paris. He has reported from five continents – most notably the War in Vietnam, The Revolution in Iran, the Civil War in Beirut, Operation Desert Storm, and Afghanistan. He also taught Literature of Journalism at New York University.
Related articles in Global Insights www.global-geneva.com
Remembering Jimmy Carter
Syria: A Bit of Historical Perspective
United States: It’s Not Just the Economy
From LA to the South of France: Combatting wildfires with global solutions
Moscow Attack Marks Return of ISIS
Forgotten Yemen Forces the US and the World to Pay Attention
Middle East: Inching Toward Armageddon
What Can Israel Do Now?
Ignoring World Opinion, Israel Steps into a Hornet’s Nest in Gaza
Biden’s Visit May Have Kept Gaza From Boiling Over
Hamas Attack Shocks Israel and Invites Massive Retaliation
The Real Cost of Ukraine
The Coup in Gabon: Just Another Incident in a Global Powershift?
On Bullshit, lies and politics: Dealing with mis/disinformation
80 Is the New (…Um, I Forgot)
Derborence: from disaster zone to birders’ paradise
Jacob Collier: accidental superstar
The Gold of Sudan and Good Old-Fashioned Russian Colonialism in Africa
The Protean Self